For overall calorie burn and bone density, a treadmill is effective, but rowing machines offer a lower impact full body workout that builds endurance and muscle simultaneously. Choose treadmills for running specific training or rowing for joint friendly, total body conditioning.
Choosing between a treadmill and a rowing machine can feel overwhelming, especially when both are staples in gyms and home setups. Each machine offers unique benefits depending on your fitness goals, body type, and lifestyle. This article breaks down the honest pros and cons of each, helping you decide which one fits your routine best.
Calorie burn and weight loss
When it comes to torching calories, both machines deliver solid results, but the numbers depend on your effort level and body weight. A 155 pound person running at 6 mph on a treadmill burns about 350 calories in 30 minutes. Rowing at a vigorous pace of 150 watts on a rowing machine burns roughly 300 calories in the same time frame. However, rowing engages more muscle groups, which can boost afterburn effect slightly more.
For pure calorie burn per minute, high intensity treadmill intervals often edge out rowing if you can sustain the impact. But rowing allows you to maintain a high heart rate with less joint stress, making it easier to go longer without injury. If your primary goal is weight loss, consistency matters more than the machine itself. Choose the one you tolerate best and are least likely to skip.
Muscle engagement and toning
Treadmills primarily work your lower body: calves, hamstrings, glutes, and quads. Incline walking adds extra glute activation. Your core engages lightly for stability, but upper body gets minimal work. Rowing machines, on the other hand, target almost every major muscle group: legs (quad drive), back (pull), arms (finish), and core (connection). Proper rowing technique requires a strong core and coordinated full body movement.
If you want to build upper body and back endurance while also strengthening legs, rowing offers a clear advantage. Treadmill running alone won’t tone your arms or shoulders. But if your focus is building lower body strength and bone density, treadmill running provides high impact loading that rowing lacks. For balanced fitness, alternating both machines gives the best of both worlds.
Impact on joints and injury risk
Treadmills produce repetitive impact, especially when running. Each foot strike loads joints with two to three times your body weight. This stress can strengthen bones and joints over time, but for people with knee, hip, or ankle issues, the pounding can worsen conditions. Walking on an incline reduces impact compared to running, but still more than rowing.
Rowing machines are nearly zero impact. Your seat glides and your feet stay strapped in, eliminating jarring forces. This makes rowing ideal for those recovering from injury, older adults, or anyone with chronic joint pain. The catch is that poor rowing form, especially rounding your back, can cause lower back strain. Both machines are safe with proper technique, but rowing is gentler on the body overall.
Sustainability and boredom factor
Running on a treadmill can feel monotonous because the movement is repetitive and limited to forward motion. Many users struggle to stick with long runs indoors. However, treadmill programs like intervals, hill climbs, and virtual classes can help. Rowing also feels repetitive, but the mix of power strokes and recovery can be more engaging if you focus on technique and pacing.
Both machines require mental grit, but rowing may offer more variety in intensity and stroke rate. For long term adherence, the best machine is the one you don’t hate. Some people prefer the hypnotic rhythm of running, while others enjoy the full body challenge of rowing. Trying each for a few weeks can reveal your personal preference.
Space, noise, and maintenance
Treadmills are bulky, heavy, and often loud. They need a dedicated floor space, and even quiet models produce footfall noise that can disturb neighbors in apartments. Maintenance includes belt lubrication and motor care. Folding treadmills save room but often sacrifice stability. Rowing machines are generally more compact, especially water or air rowers that can stand upright. They are quieter than treadmills, making them better for shared living spaces.
Rowing machines have fewer moving parts, so maintenance is lower. Air rowers use a fan that creates noise but no belt issues. Water rowers produce a soothing sound. If space and noise are concerns, rowing machines are a practical choice. However, treadmills offer handrails and a flat surface for walking or running, which some users need for balance or safety reasons.
Frequently asked questions
Which machine burns more calories: treadmill or rowing machine?
At the same effort level, treadmill running generally burns slightly more calories per minute for most people, especially at higher speeds. However, rowing engages more muscle groups and can produce a similar calorie burn with less impact.
Is rowing or treadmill better for building muscle?
Rowing builds more upper body and back muscle while also strengthening legs and core. Treadmill running mainly builds lower body muscles and can improve bone density through impact, but does little for the upper body.
Can I lose belly fat by using a rowing machine or treadmill?
Both machines can help reduce overall body fat, including belly fat, when combined with a calorie deficit. Neither targets belly fat specifically, but rowing's full body involvement may slightly boost overall metabolism.
Which is safer for bad knees?
Rowing is much safer for bad knees because it is non impact and keeps your feet planted. High impact treadmill running can aggravate knee issues, though walking on an incline is better than running.
Looking to buy? See our Treadmills guides for tested picks.
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube