The Concept2 Model D is the overall best rowing machine for its durable air resistance, accurate performance monitoring, and proven reliability. For a quieter, space-saving alternative, consider the WaterRower Natural with its water resistance and elegant design.
Check price on AmazonRowing machines offer one of the most effective full-body workouts, engaging 86% of your muscles with low impact. But not all rowers are created equal. We compared the best types of rowing machines on the market based on resistance mechanism, build quality, noise level, storage, and user satisfaction. Whether you are a beginner or seasoned rower, our research-backed roundup will help you find the perfect machine for your home gym in 2026.
Our ranking combines analysis of owner reviews, expert ratings, and technical specs across top brands like Concept2, WaterRower, and NordicTrack. We focused on the most popular categories: air, magnetic, water, air-magnetic hybrid, and dual resistance. Each pick excels in its category, but we highlight trade-offs in noise, maintenance, and price so you can choose wisely.
How we rank
We ranked these rowing machines based on a comprehensive analysis of owner reviews, expert ratings, build quality, warranty, and the specific needs of different user profiles. See our method.
Quick picks
| Best for | Product | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|
| Best Overall | Concept2 Model D | serious rowers and fitness enthusiasts who want a durable, accurate, and proven machine for intense workouts. |
| Best Value | WaterRower Natural | home users who want a quiet, attractive machine with a smooth water resistance that mimics real rowing. |
| Best for Beginners | NordicTrack RW900 | beginners who want interactive training with iFit and automatic resistance adjustments. |
| Best Budget | Schwinn 810 | budget-conscious buyers who want a decent rower with magnetic resistance and basic metrics. |
| Best Premium | Hydrow Wave | enthusiasts who want a premium connected rower with a sleek design and engaging on-demand classes. |
| Best Lightweight | Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW1205 | people with limited space or who need a lightweight, easily portable rower for light exercise. |
| Best for Cross Training | Stamina X Air Rower | athletes who want a versatile rower with air resistance that can double as a strength trainer with included resistance bands. |
The picks, compared
Concept2 Model D
The Concept2 Model D is the gold standard for rowing machines, used in gyms and competitions worldwide. Its air resistance provides a smooth, natural rowing feel that adjusts to your effort. The performance monitor tracks distance, strokes, and calories with precision. Owners report that it is nearly indestructible and holds its resale value well.
What owners say: Owners consistently praise its durability and accuracy, noting that it feels just like rowing on water. Many mention the easy folding design and the helpful community of users.
- Extremely durable and long-lasting
- Smooth, realistic air resistance
- Excellent performance monitor (PM5)
- Can be noisy compared to magnetic or water rowers
- Seat may be uncomfortable for some users without a pad
WaterRower Natural
The WaterRower Natural offers a whisper-quiet water resistance system that provides a smooth, soothing rowing experience. Its solid ash wood frame looks like furniture, making it a stylish addition to any room. Owners appreciate the minimal maintenance and the satisfying water sound. It is a great value for those who prioritize aesthetics and low noise.
What owners say: Owners love the quiet operation and the elegant wood design, saying it blends into their home decor. Many note that the water resistance feels very natural and the build quality is top-notch.
- Very quiet operation
- Beautiful wood construction
- Smooth, natural rowing feel
- Takes longer to warm up to full resistance
- Bulky and heavy
- not easily moved
NordicTrack RW900
The NordicTrack RW900 combines a silent magnetic resistance system with a pivot footplate for a comfortable stroke. It features a large tilting touchscreen for streaming iFit workouts, which automatically adjust resistance. Owners report that the guided sessions help maintain motivation and proper form. The folding design saves space when not in use.
What owners say: Owners appreciate the immersive iFit classes and the auto-resistance feature, saying it makes rowing more engaging. Some mention that the monitor could be more responsive, but overall satisfaction is high.
- Interactive iFit workouts with auto-resistance
- Quiet magnetic resistance
- Folding frame for storage
- iFit subscription required for full features
- Build quality not as robust as Concept2
Schwinn 810
The Schwinn 810 is an affordable magnetic rower that offers a quiet workout with 10 levels of resistance. It includes a simple LCD display showing time, distance, strokes, and calories. Owners find it great for light to moderate use, though serious rowers may outgrow it quickly. Its compact design and front-mounted wheels make it easy to store.
What owners say: Owners say it is a good entry-level rower for the price, praising its quiet operation and easy assembly. Some report that the resistance levels are not very challenging, but it is perfect for casual fitness.
- Very affordable
- Quiet magnetic resistance
- Compact and easy to move
- Limited resistance range
- Seat comfort could be better
Hydrow Wave
The Hydrow Wave features a compact, wall-mounted design with computer-controlled electromagnetic resistance. It offers live and on-demand classes with expert coaches, and a 16-inch HD touchscreen. Owners praise its compact footprint and the quality of the content. It is a premium offering for those who want a dedicated rowing experience without taking up too much space.
What owners say: Owners love the engaging classes and the wall-mounted design that saves floor space. Many note that the resistance feels smooth and the screen quality is excellent.
- World-class content and coaching
- Compact, wall-mountable design
- Smooth electromagnetic resistance
- Expensive
- Requires subscription for full content
Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW1205
The Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW1205 is a compact, lightweight rower with a padded seat and handlebars. It uses a smooth hydraulic piston resistance system, and an LCD display tracks basic metrics. Owners appreciate its small footprint and low price, making it ideal for small apartments. It is not for intense training but works well for gentle cardio.
What owners say: Owners like that it is easy to move around and store away, and that it provides a decent low-impact workout. Some say it feels less sturdy than larger rowers, but it serves its purpose.
- Very lightweight and portable
- Small footprint
- Quiet operation
- Hydraulic resistance may feel jerky
- Not suitable for tall users (short stroke length)
Stamina X Air Rower
The Stamina X Air Rower combines air resistance with an integrated rowing machine and a set of resistance bands for upper body exercises. The air impeller provides smooth resistance that increases with effort. Owners find it a versatile option for both rowing and strength training. It folds for storage, though it is heavier than some budget models.
What owners say: Owners appreciate the added resistance bands for a full-body workout and the smooth air resistance. Some mention that the seat could be more comfortable, but the value is solid.
- Includes resistance bands for strength training
- Smooth air resistance
- Folds for storage
- Not as durable as premium air rowers
- Monitor is basic
How to choose
- Resistance Type. Rowing machines use air, magnetic, water, or hydraulic resistance. Air rowers like Concept2 are the most realistic and widely used in gyms. Magnetic rowers are quieter and smoother, while water rowers offer a serene experience.
- Noise Level. Air rowers can be loud due to the fan, while magnetic and water rowers are quieter. If you plan to row while watching TV or in a shared space, consider a magnetic or water model.
- Footprint and Storage. Some rowers fold upright or have a compact design. Measure your space and consider how often you need to store the machine. Wall-mounted options like Hydrow Wave save floor space.
- Connectivity and Apps. Many rowers offer Bluetooth or integrated screens for streaming classes. If you need guidance or want to track progress, look for a model with app compatibility, but factor in subscription costs.
- Build Quality and Warranty. A sturdy frame and a good warranty (2+ years) indicate long-term durability. Read owner reviews about the seat, footrests, and handlebar comfort to ensure a pleasant experience.
Frequently asked questions
Which rowing machine type is most like real rowing?
Air resistance rowers such as the Concept2 Model D are considered the closest to rowing on water because resistance increases with your effort. Water rowers also mimic the feel and sound of rowing, but air rowers are more responsive.
Are magnetic rowers good for beginners?
Yes, magnetic rowers are great for beginners due to their quiet operation and smooth, consistent resistance. They are less intimidating than air rowers and often come with preset programs to guide your workout.
How much maintenance does a water rower require?
Water rowers need periodic addition of a purification tablet to prevent algae growth, and the water level should be checked. Overall, they require minimal maintenance compared to hydraulic or air rowers.
What is the difference between air and magnetic resistance?
Air resistance uses a fan that creates resistance proportional to your effort, making it self-regulating. Magnetic resistance uses magnets to create resistance that stays constant regardless of stroke intensity, which means you must manually adjust the level.
Can I fold a rowing machine for storage?
Many rowers, like the Concept2 Model D and NordicTrack RW900, can be folded upright or have a compact design for storage. Check the product specs to ensure the folding mechanism meets your space requirements.
Do I need a subscription for connected rowers?
Brands like NordicTrack and Hydrow require a paid subscription to access their full library of classes and automatic resistance adjustments. Some rowers offer free basic apps, but advanced features usually come at a cost.
The verdict
The Concept2 Model D is our top pick for its unrivaled durability, accurate performance, and proven track record. If quiet operation and style matter, go with the WaterRower Natural. For beginners who love guided workouts, the NordicTrack RW900 offers excellent value with iFit integration.
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube