
The Concept2 Model D ranks as the overall winner for its unmatched reliability and performance, while the Hydrow Wave remains a top alternative for anyone seeking a fully immersive interactive experience.
Check price on AmazonRowing machines have surged in popularity as fitness enthusiasts recognize the efficiency of full body workouts that combine cardio and strength training without high impact on joints. The market offers a wide range of options, from air resistance models used in competitive training to water based machines that simulate the feel of being on a lake. Selecting the right machine depends on your specific fitness goals, available space, and preference for digital features that can guide you through virtual rows around the world.
This roundup evaluates the most popular models currently dominating the market, focusing on durability, resistance mechanics, and the technology ecosystem that supports your training journey. We compared the leading air, magnetic, and water rowers to identify which machines offer the best value for different types of users, from beginners seeking an entry level point to advanced athletes demanding precision. Our analysis highlights the strengths and weaknesses of each contender, ensuring you can make an informed decision based on how you plan to incorporate this equipment into your routine.
How we rank
We ranked these rowing machines by analyzing aggregated user reviews, expert performance comparisons, and long term reliability data from verified owners across major retailers. See our method.
Quick picks
| Best for | Product | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|
| Best Overall | Model D with PM5 | Serious athletes and home gym enthusiasts |
| Best for Beginners | Hydrow Wave | Users wanting an immersive subscription experience |
| Best for Gamification | Ergatta Rower | Gamers and competitive personality types |
| Best Budget | SF-RW5515 Magnetic Rower | Beginners and those with limited space |
| Best Premium | RW900 Rowing Machine | Tech lovers who want global iFit integration |
| Best Value | 750R Rower | Families wanting a smart rower with silent resistance |
| Best Lightweight | 35-1405 ATS Air Rower | Users needing a portable easy to store option |
The picks, compared

Model D with PM5
The Concept2 Model D is widely considered the industry standard for indoor rowing, featuring a robust air resistance flywheel that provides a smooth and responsive feel throughout the entire stroke. Reviewers note its legendary durability, often highlighting how the machine requires minimal maintenance even after years of daily use in harsh environments. The performance monitor tracks essential metrics like pace, watts, and heart rate, allowing users to precisely measure their progress over time with scientifically validated data. Its design separates into two pieces for storage, making it surprisingly manageable for a machine of this size and capability.
What owners say: Owners frequently report that this machine feels rock solid during intense workouts, with no wiggling or shaking regardless of how hard they pull. Many users mention that the quiet flywheel sound is actually soothing and functions as white noise rather than a distraction.
- Durable construction
- Accurate performance monitor
- Easy to store
- Basic aesthetic design
- Requires 200V outlet for PM5

Hydrow Wave
Hydrow Wave utilizes electromagnetic drag technology to create a silent and smooth rowing stroke that feels significantly different from the noisy fan resistance of traditional air rowers. The standout feature is the 22 inch high definition touchscreen that broadcasts live and on demand classes from real waterways around the world, providing a captivating visual distraction. Reviewers appreciate the compact footprint and lower height profile compared to the original Hydrow, making it easier to fit into smaller living spaces while retaining the full experience. The membership service provides access to a vast library of workouts that go beyond rowing, including yoga and strength training to supplement cardio sessions.
What owners say: Owners report that the immersive video content makes it much easier to stay consistent with their workout routines compared to staring at a blank wall. Many users note that the assembly process is straightforward and that the machine operates almost silently, which is ideal for early morning sessions.
- Immersive touchscreen
- Compact footprint
- Silent operation
- Expensive subscription required
- Heavier than some rivals

Ergatta Rower
This rower uses a unique water flywheel design to generate resistance, providing a soothing sound and a tactile feel that closely mimics the dynamics of rowing a boat through water. The interface distinguishes itself by focusing entirely on game based workouts, where users race against avatars, complete challenges, and chase high scores rather than following traditional instructor led classes. Reviewers note that the cherry wood frame is aesthetically pleasing enough to leave out in a living room, functioning as a piece of furniture when not in use. The personalized difficulty engine automatically adjusts to your fitness level, ensuring that every workout remains challenging but achievable regardless of your experience.
What owners say: Owners report that the gamification element makes them look forward to workouts, turning what used to be a boring chore into an engaging competition against themselves or others. Several reviews highlight the beauty of the wood construction and confirm that the water reservoir is easy to clean and maintain.
- Game based fitness
- Beautiful wood design
- Self adjusting difficulty
- No instructor led classes
- Requires tablet or phone

SF-RW5515 Magnetic Rower
The SF-RW5515 is a magnetic rowing machine that uses a dual resistance system involving magnetic tension and adjustable fan resistance to provide a challenging workout at an affordable price point. Reviewers highlight the fully padded seat and non slip handlebars as key comfort features that help mitigate fatigue during longer rowing sessions, despite the budget positioning. The large LCD monitor displays time, count, and calories, giving users all the basic metrics needed to track their session intensity without unnecessary complexity. Its compact design includes transport wheels that make it easy to move the machine out of the way after a workout, solving the storage issues common in apartments.
What owners say: Owners report that this machine provides excellent value for the entry level price, serving as a solid introduction to rowing without requiring a massive financial commitment. Many users mention that while it is lightweight, it remains stable during use, though the seat can be uncomfortable for very tall individuals.
- Very affordable
- Compact design
- Dual resistance mechanism
- Shorter seat sliding rail
- Basic monitor display

RW900 Rowing Machine
NordicTrack equips the RW900 with a massive 22 inch rotating touchscreen that allows users to transition seamlessly from rowing to off machine floor exercises for a full body training experience. The machine uses adjustable magnetic resistance with 26 digital resistance levels, providing a wide range of intensity options that are silent during operation and controlled automatically by iFit trainers. Reviewers note that the auto adjustment feature is particularly useful because the virtual trainers can remotely increase or decrease the resistance to match the terrain of the workout. The frame construction is designed for stability, accommodating users of various sizes while folding up vertically to save floor space when not in active use.
What owners say: Owners report that the iFit integration is seamless and creates a truly studio quality experience right in the comfort of their own home. Many users note that the large screen makes following workouts very easy, though some mention that Wi-Fi connectivity issues can occasionally interrupt classes.
- Large HD touchscreen
- Integrated iFit tech
- Auto adjust resistance
- Subscription required for full use
- Large footprint even when folded

750R Rower
The ProForm 750R features a hybrid frame designed to support a smooth rowing stroke while utilizing Silent Magnetic Resistance to ensure workouts do not disturb other household members. The included 5 inch backlit display provides clear visibility of workout metrics, and it is iFit enabled, allowing users to stream live and on demand global workouts directly to the rower. Reviewers appreciate that the oversized molded seat provides comfort throughout the workout duration, reducing the risk of chafing or numbness during extended sessions. The ergonomic handle is designed with a slight angle to encourage a natural arm position, minimizing stress on the wrists and shoulders while maximizing power transfer.
What owners say: Owners report that the magnetic resistance is extremely quiet, making it the perfect machine for living spaces where noise is a concern for family members or neighbors. Users frequently mention that the assembly process is manageable and that the machine feels sturdy enough for daily exercise routines.
- Silent magnetic resistance
- iFit compatible
- Comfortable seat
- Smaller screen size
- Limited resistance levels

35-1405 ATS Air Rower
The Stamina 35-1405 ATS is an air rowing machine designed to be lightweight and foldable, making it an exceptional choice for tight spaces and frequent movement. We compared its dynamic air resistance system to rowing on water, providing a smooth workout that adjusts to the intensity of your stroke without manual controls. Reviewers note that the multi function monitor tracks basic stats like distance and speed, which are essential for maintaining a consistent training regimen without complex distractions. Its construction ensures durability while keeping weight low enough for easy transport and storage in closets or corners.
What owners say: Owners report that the machine is incredibly easy to move around the house and store in a closet when not in use due to its lighter frame. Users frequently mention that the assembly is quick and straightforward, though some note it feels less stable for heavier users compared to commercial models.
- Very lightweight frame
- Folds for storage
- Affordable price point
- Basic monitor display
- Lower weight capacity
How to choose
- Resistance Type. Water rowers mimic the feel of real water with a self regulating resistance level that increases with your speed. Magnetic rowers are typically quieter and offer adjustable resistance levels via digital controls, though they may lack the natural inertia of air or water models.
- Monitor and Connectivity. Advanced rowers come with high definition touchscreens that stream workout classes and provide real time feedback on form and metrics. Basic models feature simpler LCD displays that track time and distance, which is sufficient for users who prefer to train without monthly subscription fees.
- Comfort and Fit. The seat should be well padded and sufficiently wide to ensure comfort during extended workout sessions exceeding thirty minutes. It is crucial to check the weight capacity and rail length to ensure the machine accommodates your specific height and body type safely.
- Storage and Portability. Many modern rowing machines feature folding frames or unique vertical storage capabilities to minimize the footprint when the equipment is not in use. Look for transportation wheels on the front stabilizer to make moving the machine easier across different floor surfaces.
- Noise Level. Air resistance rowers produce a noticeable whooshing sound that increases with intensity, which can be a factor for apartment dwellers. Magnetic and water resistance models operate significantly quieter, making them ideal options for shared living spaces or early morning workouts.
Frequently asked questions
Is rowing a good workout for weight loss?
Rowing is an exceptional calorie burning exercise that engages both upper and lower body muscle groups simultaneously. It provides an efficient cardiovascular workout that can help maintain a caloric deficit essential for weight loss while preserving lean muscle mass.
How often should I use my rowing machine?
Consistency is key, so most experts recommend rowing three to five times per week for at least twenty minutes per session. Beginners should start slowly to build proper form and endurance before increasing the duration and intensity of their workouts.
Do rowing machines require a lot of maintenance?
Air rowers like the Concept2 are low maintenance, requiring only periodic cleaning of the flywheel and chain oiling. Water rowers need more attention to keep the water treated with purification tablets to prevent bacterial growth and algae buildup in the tank.
Can I row every day without injury?
Rowing is a low impact activity that is generally safe for daily use as long as you vary your intensity and focus on technique. However, beginners should allow for rest days to let their muscles recover and adapt to the new movement patterns to prevent overuse injuries.
What is the difference between air and magnetic resistance?
Air resistance relies on a flywheel that generates resistance based on the speed of your pull, offering a dynamic feeling similar to outdoor rowing. Magnetic resistance uses magnets to create drag against a metal flywheel, providing a quieter and more consistent resistance level that is usually adjustable via levers or digital buttons.
Does a rowing machine build muscle?
Yes, rowing is a comprehensive strength builder that targets major muscle groups including the legs, back, arms, and core. By increasing resistance and focusing on power strokes, you can build muscular endurance and strength in your posterior chain effectively.
The verdict
The Concept2 Model D remains the overall winner due to its unmatched durability, accurate performance tracking, and widespread acceptance as the training standard. For those seeking a modern, high tech experience, the Hydrow Wave offers an immersive alternative that keeps users engaged with scenic content and guided classes. Meanwhile, budget conscious buyers should consider the Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515 for a basic yet effective introduction to rowing.
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube