The Concept2 Model D is the overall best rowing machine thanks to its proven durability, accurate performance monitoring, and strong resale value. For a more compact option, consider the WaterRower Natural, which offers a space-saving design and smooth water resistance.
Check price on AmazonRowing machines deliver a full-body workout that engages 86% of your muscles, making them one of the most efficient cardio tools for home gyms. At SweatPicks, we combed through hundreds of owner reviews, YouTube comparisons, and expert analyses to find the best rowing machines that actually deliver results. Whether you’re a competitive rower or a beginner, we ranked the top rowers based on build quality, resistance type, monitor features, and long-term user satisfaction.
To create this ranking, we looked at real-world feedback from owners on forums, retailer reviews, and video breakdowns. We focused on machines that offer smooth motion, reliable performance, and good warranty support. Our picks range from air rowers to magnetic and water resistance models, so you can choose the one that fits your space and workout style. No fluff, just the facts that matter.
How we rank
We analyzed owner reviews from major retailers and YouTube comparison videos, focusing on durability, resistance quality, and user satisfaction over time. See our method.
Quick picks
| Best for | Product | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|
| Best Overall | Concept2 Model D with PM5 | Serious rowers and home gym owners who want a durable, accurate machine |
| Best Value | WaterRower Natural | Those who want a quiet, smooth rowing experience with a stylish design |
| Best for Interactive Workouts | NordicTrack RW900 | Users who want iFit streaming classes and automatic resistance adjustment |
| Best Premium | Hydrow Wave | Rowers who want a premium live-streaming fitness experience |
| Best for Low Impact | Bowflex Max Trainer M6 | Users who want low-impact, full-body cardio with a vertical stepping motion |
| Best Budget | Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515 | Budget-conscious buyers who want a basic yet functional magnetic rower |
| Best for Beginners | ProForm Performance 400i | First-time rowers who want an easy-to-use machine with guided workouts |
The picks, compared
Concept2 Model D with PM5
The Concept2 Model D is the gold standard in rowing. Used in gyms and competitions worldwide, it features air resistance that adjusts to your effort, a versatile PM5 monitor with Bluetooth connectivity, and a foldable frame for storage. Owners praise its bulletproof construction and consistent performance. The machine is easy to maintain and holds its resale value exceptionally well.
What owners say: Owners consistently report the Model D as a workhorse that lasts for years with minimal maintenance. Many appreciate the accurate split times and the active online community for workouts.
- Excellent build quality and durability
- Accurate PM5 monitor with apps and games
- Folds upright for compact storage
- Seat can feel hard on longer sessions
- Air resistance can be loud
WaterRower Natural
The WaterRower Natural uses water resistance to simulate the feel of rowing on water. Its solid ash frame looks like fine furniture, and the water tank provides a calming, quiet stroke. The S4 monitor tracks distance, time, and strokes per minute. Owners love the natural rowing motion and the aesthetic appeal, though the tank requires occasional maintenance.
What owners say: Owners highlight the smooth, quiet operation and the beautiful design that fits into living spaces. Some note that the monitor is basic compared to the Concept2 and that the tank can grow algae if not treated.
- Smooth and quiet water resistance
- Beautiful hardwood frame
- Compact footprint when vertical
- Monitor lacks advanced connectivity
- Water tank maintenance required
NordicTrack RW900
The NordicTrack RW900 features silent magnetic resistance and a large 22-inch tilt and pivot touchscreen for iFit workouts. The resistance auto-adjusts during trainer-led classes, and the machine folds for storage. Owners enjoy the immersive video workouts and the quiet operation, but some note that the subscription is necessary to unlock full functionality.
What owners say: Owners love the interactive iFit classes and auto-resistance feature for a guided experience. Some report reliability issues with the console and that the machine feels less durable than a Concept2.
- Large rotating touchscreen with iFit
- Auto-adjusting magnetic resistance
- Quiet and smooth operation
- Requires ongoing iFit subscription
- Some reports of monitor glitches
Hydrow Wave
The Hydrow Wave uses computer-controlled electromagnetic resistance that adapts to your stroke, paired with a 16-inch touchscreen for live and on-demand rowing classes. It has a sleek, low-profile design that can be stored vertically. Owners appreciate the high-energy instruction and the smooth resistance curve, but the subscription cost is a factor to consider.
What owners say: Owners emphasize the engaging instructor-led sessions and the quiet, smooth resistance. Some mention that the subscription is pricey and that the machine is heavy to move.
- Excellent live and on-demand classes
- Smooth electromagnetic resistance
- Compact vertical storage
- Monthly subscription required
- Heavy at 125 lb
Bowflex Max Trainer M6
The Bowflex Max Trainer M6 combines rowing, stepping, and elliptical motion in one machine. It uses resistance bands for a low-impact, high-calorie burn. The console tracks metrics like calories and heart rate. Owners like the low joint impact and the ability to change resistance easily, but some feel the motion takes time to get used to.
What owners say: Owners note the effective low-impact workout and the compact footprint. Some express that the resistance bands can lose tension over time and that the machine is not a pure rower.
- Very low impact on joints
- Combines multiple cardio motions
- Resistance bands provide smooth feel
- Not a traditional rowing motion
- Resistance may not be enough for advanced users
Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515
The Sunny SF-RW5515 is an affordable magnetic rower that offers 8 levels of resistance and a simple LCD monitor. It folds for storage and has a comfortable padded seat. Owners appreciate the value for the price and the whisper-quiet operation, though some note the monitor is basic and the seat can be squeaky over time.
What owners say: Owners find it a solid entry-level rower that is quiet and easy to use. Many comment that it works well for casual workouts but lacks the durability for intense daily use.
- Very affordable
- Quiet magnetic resistance
- Foldable and lightweight
- Basic monitor with limited metrics
- Some users report seat squeaking after a few months
ProForm Performance 400i
The ProForm Performance 400i features SMR silent magnetic resistance and a pair of large pedals. It includes 24 preset workout apps and a 5-inch backlit display. The machine is designed for comfort with an oversized seat and adjustable foot pedals. Owners like the smooth motion and the structured workouts, but some find the console basic and the frame a bit lightweight.
What owners say: Owners appreciate the preset workouts that guide beginners and the quiet operation. Some note that the resistance range is limited and that the display could be larger.
- 24 preset workout programs
- Smooth magnetic resistance
- Comfortable oversized seat
- Limited max resistance
- Monitor is small and basic
How to choose
- Resistance Type. Air resistance (like Concept2) provides a linear feel and is durable but louder. Water resistance offers a soothing sound and yacht-like feel but requires maintenance. Magnetic resistance is quiet and smooth, great for apartments.
- Monitor Features. Look for a monitor that tracks distance, time, strokes per minute, and split times. Bluetooth connectivity and app integration (like PM5 or iFit) add value for structured training.
- Foldability and Storage. If space is tight, choose a model that folds upright or stores vertically. The Concept2 folds, while the WaterRower can stand on end. Check dimensions in storage mode.
- Build Quality and Warranty. A strong frame (steel or solid wood) and a high weight capacity indicate durability. Look for at least a 2-year warranty on the frame and 1 year on parts and labor.
- User Height and Weight. Make sure the rower accommodates your height with an adjustable footrest and a long rail. Check weight capacity to ensure it supports your body weight plus headroom.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most durable rowing machine?
The Concept2 Model D is widely regarded as the most durable, with many owners reporting over 10 years of use with minimal maintenance. Its air resistance system is simple and has few moving parts.
Are water rowers better than air rowers?
It depends on preference. Water rowers like the WaterRower provide a smoother, quieter stroke and a more realistic feel, but the water tank requires cleaning. Air rowers are more durable and offer precise performance tracking.
Do I need a subscription for rowing machines?
Not all. The Concept2 Model D works without a subscription, but you can connect third-party apps. Hydrow and NordicTrack RW900 require a monthly subscription for full access to their workout libraries.
Can rowing machines help with weight loss?
Yes, rowing burns up to 600 calories per hour and engages multiple muscle groups, making it an effective full-body exercise for weight loss when combined with a healthy diet.
How much space does a rowing machine need?
Most rowers require about 8 feet of floor space when extended. Many models fold or store vertically, reducing the footprint to around 2 feet by 3 feet.
What is the quietest rowing machine?
Magnetic and water rowers are typically the quietest. The Sunny SF-RW5515 and the NordicTrack RW900 are both very quiet, making them suitable for apartments.
The verdict
For most buyers, the Concept2 Model D is the best overall rowing machine due to its unbeatable durability, accuracy, and resale value. If you prefer a quieter, more aesthetic machine, the WaterRower Natural is an excellent alternative. For those wanting guided training, the Hydrow Wave offers an immersive experience with premium classes.
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube