The best rowing machine with water resistance is the WaterRower Natural, praised for its smooth, realistic feel and solid wood construction. For a budget-friendly alternative, the Sunny Health & Fitness Water Rowing Machine offers a similar experience at a lower cost, with good reviews for its compact design and quiet operation.
Check price on AmazonWater rowing machines mimic the natural feel of rowing on water, using a water flywheel for smooth, quiet resistance. They are popular for full-body workouts that engage legs, core, and arms without the jarring impact of other cardio equipment. With many models on the market, we ranked the best water rowers based on owner reviews, build quality, resistance consistency, and space efficiency.
Our rankings are based on a thorough analysis of owner testimonials across multiple review platforms, focusing on long-term durability, comfort, and overall satisfaction. We prioritized machines that offer a smooth rowing stroke, sturdy construction, and features that enhance workout experience. Whether you are a beginner or a seasoned rower, our list covers options to fit different needs and preferences.
How we rank
We ranked these water rowing machines by aggregating and analyzing owner reviews from major retailers and fitness forums, focusing on durability, rowing feel, noise level, and overall satisfaction over time. See our method.
Quick picks
| Best for | Product | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|
| Best Overall | WaterRower Natural | Home gyms seeking premium build and authentic rowing feel |
| Best Value | Sunny Health & Fitness Water Rowing Machine | Budget-conscious buyers who want water resistance without breaking the bank |
| Best for Interactive Training | Hydrow Wave | Those who want guided rowing workouts with a premium streaming experience |
| Best for Performance Tracking | Concept2 Model D with PM5 | Serious rowers and crossfitters who want precise data and durability |
| Best Premium | Life Fitness Row HX | Commercial-grade home use with smooth water-like resistance |
| Best Budget | Stamina ATS Air Rower | Buyers on a tight budget who still want a smooth rowing experience |
| Best Lightweight | Magnus Fitness Magnetic Water Rower | Users needing a lightweight, portable water rower with smooth resistance |
The picks, compared
WaterRower Natural
The WaterRower Natural is the gold standard for water rowing machines, featuring a handcrafted solid ash wood frame that doubles as furniture. Its water flywheel provides a smooth, quiet, and natural rowing stroke that closely simulates on-water experience. Owners consistently report exceptional build quality and longevity, with many using the machine daily for years without issues. The integrated S4 monitor tracks essential metrics like distance, time, and strokes per minute, making it easy to monitor progress.
What owners say: Owners praise the WaterRower's elegant design that blends into home decor, and the quiet, smooth resistance that allows for TV watching or conversation. Many note the assembly is straightforward and the machine feels rock-solid even during intense workouts.
- Smooth, natural water resistance feel
- Beautiful solid wood construction
- Quiet operation suitable for apartments
- Higher price point than competitors
- Monitor is basic with no Bluetooth or apps
Sunny Health & Fitness Water Rowing Machine
The Sunny Health & Fitness Water Rowing Machine offers a great entry point into water rowing at a more accessible price. It features a steel frame and a water tank that provides smooth, adjustable resistance based on your stroke power. The LCD monitor displays time, distance, calories, and stroke count, while the padded seat and comfort foot pedals ensure longer workouts are enjoyable. Owners appreciate the value for money and the fact that it folds upright for compact storage.
What owners say: Reviewers highlight the smooth rowing motion and quiet operation for the price, though some mention the monitor is basic and the construction feels less premium than high-end models. Many say it is a solid machine for regular use.
- Affordable water rower
- Folding design saves space
- Smooth resistance and quiet operation
- Monitor lacks advanced features
- Frame may feel less sturdy over time with heavy use
Hydrow Wave
Hydrow Wave brings interactive, live-class style rowing to the water resistance category with a compact design. It uses computer-controlled electromagnetic drag to simulate water resistance, offering a realistic feel in a smaller footprint. The 16-inch HD touchscreen streams thousands of on-demand and live classes led by professional athletes. Owners love the engaging workouts and the community aspect, while the water-like resistance is smooth and adjustable. The Wave is designed for easy storage and assembly.
What owners say: Owners report the Hydrow Wave transforms their workout routine with coach-led classes that keep them motivated. The magnetically assisted water-like resistance is praised for being smooth and nearly silent, though some note the subscription cost adds up.
- Engaging live and on-demand classes
- Compact and easy to store
- Smooth, water-like resistance
- Requires monthly subscription for full content
- Higher price than basic water rowers
Concept2 Model D with PM5
While not a water rower, the Concept2 Model D with PM5 monitor uses air resistance but is often compared to water rowers for its smooth, adjustable feel. It is the gold standard in rowing machines for performance tracking and durability, used by elite athletes and gyms worldwide. The PM5 monitor provides accurate metrics including pace, stroke rate, heart rate, and can sync with apps like Zwift and ErgData. Owners consistently rate it highest for build quality and resale value, though the air resistance is noisier than water rowers.
What owners say: Owners rave about the Concept2's unmatched durability and the wealth of data from the PM5 monitor. Many say it lasts for decades with minimal maintenance, although the wind noise is a common complaint compared to water rowers.
- Industry standard for accuracy and durability
- Advanced PM5 monitor with connectivity
- Easy to maintain and store (folds for storage)
- Air resistance is noisier than water
- No water resistance feel
- less aesthetic for home
Life Fitness Row HX
The Life Fitness Row HX uses a water-based resistance system that delivers a smooth, natural rowing motion, complemented by a polished design suitable for upscale home gyms. The frame is built with high-quality materials for stability, and the large seat and footrests provide exceptional comfort. The console offers multiple workout programs and tracks essential metrics. Owners appreciate the quiet operation and the solid feel of the machine, which rivals commercial gym equipment.
What owners say: Reviewers note the Row HX feels incredibly sturdy and smooth, with a resistance that mimics rowing on water closely. The large display is easy to read, and the machine folds for space saving, though the premium price is a barrier for some.
- Commercial-grade build quality
- Extremely smooth and quiet water resistance
- Comfortable seat and ergonomic design
- Very expensive
- Large footprint even when folded
Stamina ATS Air Rower
The Stamina ATS Air Rower uses a wind resistance fan that provides a smooth, progressive feel similar to water rowers, though it is not water-based. It is one of the most affordable rowing machines on the market, making it accessible for beginners. The ATS (Air Tuned Suspension) system uses a fan to create resistance that increases with effort, offering a decent workout. The monitor tracks basic metrics, and the padded seat ensures comfort. Owners often mention it as a great starter rower that does the job without breaking the bank.
What owners say: Owners appreciate the low cost and the surprisingly smooth resistance, though some note the build quality feels less durable. Many say it is a good entry-level machine for light to moderate use, but not for heavy rowers.
- Very affordable price
- Air resistance is smooth and quiet enough
- Compact and lightweight for storage
- Less durable frame
- Monitor is very basic
Magnus Fitness Magnetic Water Rower
The Magnus Fitness Magnetic Water Rower combines a water tank with magnetic resistance for a unique smooth feel and adjustable intensity. It is one of the lightest water rowing machines, making it easy to move and store. The frame is made from aircraft-grade aluminum, and the tank uses a water flywheel with magnetic braking for consistent resistance. The LCD monitor shows time, distance, calories, and pulse. Owners like the portability and the quiet operation, though the magnetic resistance may feel less like real rowing.
What owners say: Reviewers mention the lightweight design makes it easy to move from room to room, and the resistance is smooth and quiet. Some find the magnetic element reduces the authentic water feel, but it is a good compromise for portability.
- Very lightweight and portable
- Smooth magnetic-assisted water resistance
- Quiet operation
- Resistance feels less authentic than pure water
- Monitor and build not as premium
How to choose
- Resistance Type: Water vs. Air vs. Magnetic. Water rowers use a water flywheel for a natural, quiet stroke that mimics on-water rowing. Air rowers use a fan and are louder but provide more accurate data for performance tracking. Magnetic rowers use magnets for silent, adjustable resistance but lack the realistic feel. Choose based on your preference for noise, feel, and data tracking.
- Build Quality and Materials. Look for a sturdy frame made of steel or hardwood like ash or oak. High-end models like the WaterRower use solid wood that lasts for years, while budget models may use lighter steel that can wobble under heavy use. Check the maximum user weight rating to ensure the machine can handle your size and intensity.
- Monitor Features and Connectivity. Basic monitors show time, distance, strokes, and calories. Advanced monitors offer heart rate monitoring, Bluetooth connectivity, and app integration for structured workouts. If you want to follow training programs or compete virtually, choose a model with a PM5 or similar smart monitor.
- Space and Storage. Water rowers are typically longer than other types, so measure your space. Many models fold upright for storage, but some require a larger footprint. Consider the weight and whether you need to move it frequently. Lightweight models around 45 lbs are easier to relocate.
- Comfort and Ergonomics. A contoured, cushioned seat and adjustable footrests improve comfort for long sessions. The handle should be comfortable to grip, and the rail length should accommodate your leg length. Test or read reviews about seat comfort and handle grip to avoid discomfort during extended use.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between water rowers and air rowers?
Water rowers use a water-filled flywheel to create resistance through paddles, offering a smooth, quiet, and realistic rowing feel. Air rowers use a fan that creates resistance with air, which is louder but provides more precise data and is often preferred by competitive rowers for performance tracking.
Do water rowing machines require maintenance?
Yes, water rowers require periodic maintenance to keep the water tank clean and clear. You should add a water purification tablet every 3-6 months to prevent algae growth, and occasionally check the seals for leaks. Some models allow you to adjust water level to change resistance, but this is rarely needed.
Are water rowing machines quiet enough for apartments?
Yes, water rowers are among the quietest types of rowing machines. The sound of water swishing is white noise, typically under 60 decibels, which is comparable to a normal conversation. This makes them suitable for apartments, especially if placed on a mat for additional sound dampening.
Which water rower is best for beginners?
The Sunny Health & Fitness Water Rowing Machine is a great choice for beginners due to its affordable price, straightforward assembly, and smooth water resistance that is easy to adjust by rowing harder. It also folds for storage, making it ideal for smaller spaces.
Can I use a water rower for high-intensity interval training (HIIT)?
Yes, water rowers are excellent for HIIT because the resistance increases naturally with your effort, providing a scalable workout. The smooth stroke allows for fast, explosive movements without jarring impact. Many models like the WaterRower and Sunny can handle intense intervals.
What is the warranty on a WaterRower?
WaterRower offers a 5-year warranty on the frame and a 3-year warranty on components. Their customer service is well-regarded. Other brands like Sunny Health & Fitness typically offer 1-2 years on parts. Always check the warranty before purchasing.
The verdict
For most home gyms, the WaterRower Natural is the clear overall pick, offering unmatched build quality and a rowing feel that closely mirrors actual water rowing. If you want interactive coaching and a compact design, the Hydrow Wave is an excellent choice. For those on a budget, the Sunny Health & Fitness Water Rower provides a great water resistance experience without breaking the bank.
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube