The Concept2 Model D is the overall best rowing machine for exercise due to its unbeatable durability, performance monitoring, and community. For a quieter, more immersive experience, the WaterRower Natural is a top alternative.
Check price on AmazonRowing machines offer one of the most effective full-body workouts, engaging 86% of your muscles while being low-impact. With so many options on the market, choosing the right rower for your home gym can be overwhelming. We compared the top models based on resistance type (air, magnetic, water, hydraulic), build quality, noise level, and thousands of verified owner reviews to help you make an informed decision.
Our research focused on real-world feedback from owners, not just marketing claims. We looked at durability, comfort, storage, and overall satisfaction to rank these rowing machines. Whether you are a beginner or a seasoned rower, our list covers the best options for different needs and spaces.
How we rank
We ranked these rowing machines by analyzing owner reviews, comparing resistance systems, build materials, and features across major brands. See our method.
Quick picks
| Best for | Product | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|
| Best Overall | Concept2 Model D Indoor Rower | serious rowers and home gyms |
| Best Premium | WaterRower Natural Rowing Machine | those wanting a quiet, aesthetic rower |
| Best for Interactive Training | NordicTrack RW900 Rowing Machine | interactive workout lovers |
| Best for Streamed Classes | Hydrow Wave Rowing Machine | class lovers who want a compact rower |
| Best Value | Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515 Magnetic Rowing Machine | budget-conscious buyers |
| Best for CrossFit | Rogue Oar Rower Black Anodized | high-intensity interval training |
| Best Lightweight | Magnetic Rowing Machine by Stamina Avari Series | small spaces and portability |
The picks, compared
Concept2 Model D Indoor Rower
The Concept2 Model D is the gold standard for rowing machines, trusted by gyms and competitive rowers worldwide. Its air resistance system self-adjusts to your effort, providing a smooth and natural feel. The PM5 monitor tracks pace, distance, calories, and heart rate with reliable accuracy. Owners praise its durability and the vibrant online community for workouts and challenges.
What owners say: Owners consistently report that the Concept2 is built to last, with many using it for years without issues. The PM5 monitor is widely praised for its clarity and connectivity, though some mention the noise level is higher than water or magnetic rowers.
- Extremely durable and long-lasting
- Accurate performance monitor with great community support
- Smooth, natural rowing feel with adjustable air resistance
- Noisier than water or magnetic rowers
- Does not fold
- vertical storage kit sold separately
WaterRower Natural Rowing Machine
The WaterRower Natural combines a beautiful handcrafted wood frame with a water resistance system that mimics the feel of real rowing. The swoosh of the water is soothing and much quieter than air rowers, making it ideal for home use. Owners love its elegant design and the smooth, progressive resistance. It is a premium investment that adds style to any room.
What owners say: Owners rave about the aesthetic appeal and whisper-quiet operation, often placing it in living areas. The water resistance feels very natural, though some note that the water can slosh if not filled properly and occasional maintenance is needed to treat the water.
- Beautiful wood craftsmanship and quiet operation
- Realistic water rowing feel
- Space-saving vertical storage option (requires kit)
- Heavier and more expensive than other types
- Water treatment required to prevent algae
NordicTrack RW900 Rowing Machine
The NordicTrack RW900 offers a 22-inch tilting touchscreen with iFit membership, providing studio classes and scenery rows that automatically adjust resistance. Its silent magnetic resistance system is quiet and smooth. Owners enjoy the immersive training experience and the ability to row around the world. The foldable design saves floor space when not in use.
What owners say: Users appreciate the engaging iFit content and automatic resistance changes, but some report issues with screen reliability and customer service. The foldability is a plus for storage, though it remains heavy.
- Large tilting screen with interactive iFit workouts
- Smooth and quiet magnetic resistance
- Foldable for easier storage
- Requires iFit subscription for full features
- Some reliability concerns with electronics
Hydrow Wave Rowing Machine
The Hydrow Wave is a more compact and affordable version of the original Hydrow, offering the same streaming library of rowing and cross-training classes. Its electromagnetic resistance provides a smooth and quiet feel. The 16-inch screen rotates for floor exercises. Owners love the energetic instructors and the sense of community, but note that the subscription is required for full use.
What owners say: Owners praise the motivated instructor-led workouts and the compact footprint. Common criticisms include the mandatory subscription cost and that the screen is smaller than the original Hydrow.
- Access to live and on-demand classes with top coaches
- Quiet electromagnetic resistance
- Compact design with rotating screen
- Requires ongoing membership for most features
- Resistance may feel lighter at max compared to air rowers
Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515 Magnetic Rowing Machine
The Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515 offers magnetic resistance at a low price point, making it an excellent entry-level rower. It has 8 levels of resistance, a simple LCD display, and a comfortable padded seat. Owners find it effective for basic cardio workouts and appreciate the included tablet holder and transportation wheels. It is not as refined as premium models but gets the job done.
What owners say: Owners generally find it good value for the price, though some mention the resistance range is limited and the monitor is basic. Assembly is straightforward, but build quality is not as robust as higher-end rowers.
- Very affordable magnetic rower
- Compact and easy to move with wheels
- Quiet operation suitable for apartments
- Resistance may not challenge strong rowers
- LCD monitor lacks advanced metrics
Rogue Oar Rower Black Anodized
Built like a tank, the Rogue Oar Rower is designed for intense workouts and repeated use in commercial or home gyms. It uses air resistance with a large fan wheel and a reinforced steel frame. The handle and seat are ergonomic, and the monitor tracks key metrics. Owners appreciate its ruggedness and smooth rowing motion, but it is tall and takes up floor space.
What owners say: CrossFit enthusiasts and heavy users love the durability and the consistent resistance. Some owners note that the monitor is basic and the rower is not as polished as Concept2, but it can take a beating.
- Extremely durable steel frame
- Smooth air resistance suitable for HIIT
- Lifetime frame warranty
- Tall height may be an issue for shorter ceilings
- Monitor lacks Bluetooth and some features
Magnetic Rowing Machine by Stamina Avari Series
The Stamina Avari Magnetic Rower is lightweight and folds for easy storage, making it ideal for apartments or those with limited space. It has magnetic resistance with 8 levels, a comfortable seat, and an LCD monitor. Owners find it easy to move and store, though it may not suit taller users or intense training. It is a decent option for introducing rowing into your routine.
What owners say: Owners appreciate the low price and portability; many use it for light cardio. However, tall users report the stride length is short, and the resistance is not challenging enough for advanced rowers.
- Lightweight and folds compactly
- Very quiet operation
- Easy to assemble and move
- Short stride length
- not ideal for tall users
- Limited resistance levels and basic monitor
How to choose
- Resistance Type. Choose between air, magnetic, water, or hydraulic. Air provides a natural feel but is loud. Magnetic is quiet and smooth, water mimics rowing, and hydraulic is compact but less smooth.
- Machine Size and Storage. Measure your space before buying. Some rowers fold vertically or horizontally for storage. Others require a dedicated spot. Check the length and height, especially for tall users.
- Monitor and Connectivity. Basic monitors show time, distance, and calories. Advanced ones have Bluetooth, heart rate monitoring, and app connectivity. If you want structured workouts, consider models with screens and subscriptions.
- Noise Level. Air rowers are louder, water rowers produce a soothing swoosh, and magnetic rowers are very quiet. Consider your living situation and whether you will row while others are nearby.
- Build Quality and Weight Capacity. Steel frames last longer and support heavier users. Check the weight capacity and warranty. Cheaper rowers may wobble or fail over time with heavy use.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best rowing machine for weight loss?
For weight loss, the Concept2 Model D is often recommended because it provides consistent, measurable workouts and allows you to burn calories efficiently. The ability to track your progress and compete with others helps maintain motivation.
Are rowing machines good for beginners?
Yes, rowing machines are excellent for beginners because they offer a low-impact, full-body workout. Starting with a magnetic rower like the Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515 can be gentle on joints while building endurance.
Which rowing machine is quietest?
Magnetic and electromagnetic rowers are the quietest, such as the NordicTrack RW900 or Hydrow Wave. Water rowers produce a calming water sound but are still relatively quiet compared to air rowers.
How much space do I need for a rowing machine?
Most rowing machines require about 8 feet in length and 2-3 feet in width. Some models like the Stamina Avari fold down to a much smaller footprint. Always measure your space and consider vertical storage options.
Do I need a subscription for a rowing machine?
Not all rowing machines require a subscription. Basic models like the Concept2 or Sunny rower work without one. However, interactive rowers like NordicTrack RW900 and Hydrow Wave require a monthly fee for full access to classes and features.
How do I maintain a water rower?
Water rowers require adding a water purification tablet every 3-6 months to prevent algae growth. Secure the bung tight after filling to avoid leaks. Some users add a small amount of white vinegar to keep the water clear.
The verdict
The Concept2 Model D is our overall top pick for its durability, performance, and community support. For a quieter, premium experience with interactive training, the NordicTrack RW900 is ideal. If you are on a budget, the Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515 offers solid value for beginners.